Day 25: Learning to Document Properly

Documentation is a polemic topic in programming because there are so many ways of doing it. While everyone agrees at some level that software documentation is important, there is rarely agreement between two programmers on exactly what needs to be documented and how.

Despite the misunderstandings, there are still some common practices that can be incorporated in a daily development workflow. To simplify, let us start discussing some areas of a code base where most everyone agrees that there should be extensive documentation: the public API. We will see why and how such interfaces should be documented, and then move to other cases.

Documenting APIs

If there is a part of a code base that really needs good documentation, that is the external API. This is specially important because, in many cases, the interface of the library is the only part of the code available to users. This is a common situation in languages such as C++, where header files can be distributed independently from the implementation sources. A similar case happens when only the Javadoc files are distributed for a Java library.

When the source code for a library is not distributed, the comments in the public API are the only way to determine how to properly use an interface — in the absence of a more extensive manual. Moreover, even if the complete source code of a library is accessible, API developers need to remember that it is sometimes a hassle to look up the implementation for an API — especially when a code browser is not available. Whatever the situation, looking at the implementation files should not be necessary to understand how to properly use an API.

When documenting libraries, it is very important to provide clear examples of how a method can be called, and if possible, the context in which such a call is correct. Sadly, many libraries come with documentation that provides detailed explanations for each method individually, but fails at explaining how that method can be used along with other classes to achieve a desired result. This is a frustrating experience for programmers, and can make your library harder to use, even if it is well designed and implemented.

Documenting Internal Header Files

Header files that are internal to the project have many of the same challenges presented by external libraries. In a sense, each header file is a mini API that defines how other parts of the library or application will interact with that specific section of the code. For this reason, programmers need to be careful to present a complete picture of what that module or class are trying to accomplish.

On the other hand, many internal header files have low importance when viewed along with other parts of the code base. Because they are mostly used as an implementation detail, several of these internal header files and classes don’t really require further explanation. Depending on the particular phase of the project, these files may be frequently written and modified, and are subject to changes that may render any documentation useless within a short time span. Therefore, providing extensive documentation for some private classes and header files may be completely unnecessary.

A common guideline when working with internal header files is to treat them according with their relative importance to the project. There are some small header files, containing only POD classes, for example, that don’t require any time spent in documentation. These are essentially dependent files, which receive their meaning from other, more important definitions in the project.

More important header files should receive better documentation, however. For example, classes that encapsulate fundamental concepts in the application should be fully document, sometimes with as much care as one would spend when writing external APIs.

Documenting Internal Code

Internal code is the easiest to handle, because developers have complete control over what it will look like. At the same time, it is the most contentious area in code documentation because each software author has a different idea of what needs to be documented or not.

General guidelines are still possible here. It is now understood that there is little value in trying to document “how” something is done. For example, the typical comment:

i++; // increment the counter “i”

should be avoided at all costs: it just adds more noise to the code, without contributing anything. Any C++ or Java programmer will be completely familiar with the meaning of the line of code above. It would be a different situation, however, if the comment tried to explain “why” the expression is necessary:

i++; // incrementing here because the next section assumes? // all counters have been updated

The comment is now useful. Its purpose is clear, and it explains in a few words why the counter needs to be updated at this particular location, and not after the next instructions are executed.

It is easy to understand the difference between “how” and “why” comments once you start asking these questions yourself. Whenever you are about create a new comment, think first: is this describing what happens or why it happens? The first type of comment should be avoided. The second type of comment may be useful enough to warrant its inclusion.

Conclusion

Commenting code is an stylistic decision. Every programmer has a different way to handle comments. Some developers never write comments, while a few others like to create small essays for each section of code (consider, for example, literate programming).

Despite the differences, comments should always be handled with proper care. They are more important when code is made available to external users, who don’t have access to the implementation. They should also appear in sections of the code where an explanation is necessary for a complete understanding — clearly describing why, instead of just how, something is done.

Similar Posts:

Similar Posts

20 Comments

  1. ?????? ????????? ?????? ????!
    ChatGPT-4 — ??? ??????? ? ??????? ? ?????????. ????????? ????? ?? ???????? ???????, ???????????? ?????? ? ?????, ????????? ?????? ?? ?????????? ????????? ??? ???????? ????? ? ChatGPT. ??? ??????????? ???????? ChatGPT ??? ?????? — ?????????????? ????????? ???????? ? ????? ??? ?????? ??????. ?????????????, ????????, ??????????? — ??? ? ????? ???????????!
    ?????????: https://yarchatgpt.ru
    ???? ?? ???

    ?????????? ???????? — ?????????? ?????????!

  2. I’m amazed, I have to admit. Rarely do I come across a blog that’s equally
    educative and engaging, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head.
    The problem is an issue that not enough men and women are speaking intelligently about.
    Now i’m very happy I found this in my search for something concerning this.

  3. Thanks a lot for sharing this with all of us you actually know what
    you are talking approximately! Bookmarked. Please additionally
    talk over with my web site =). We can have a link alternate agreement among us

  4. Bekannt ist Holland aber für seine Kunst und Malerei, berühmte Maler sind unter anderem Jan Vermeer, Rembrandt van Rijn,
    Vincent van Gogh sowie Piet Mondrian. Weltberühmte Mühlen prägen das Landschaftsbild, kilometerlange traumhafte
    Strände locken Badegäste an. Druckfehler und
    Irrtümer vorbehalten.Da jedes Casino kurzfristige Änderungen vornehmen kann, bitte immer auch auf der jeweiligen Casinoseite nachschauen! Zum ersten Mal kommt auch der WSOP Circuit ins Holland Casino Amsterdam.

    Für all diejenigen, die nach Alternativen suchen, bieten sich andere Casinos in der Umgebung an, die ebenfalls
    spannende Spieloptionen und hervorragende Gastronomie
    bieten. Im Fokus steht jedoch das Pokerspiel, mit einem vielfältigen Angebot an Cash Games und Turnieren, die für alle
    Erfahrungsstufen geeignet sind. Um die Vorteile zu nutzen, müssen Besucher vor dem Verlassen des Casinos ihre Eintrittskarte zusammen mit dem Entwertungsgutschein scannen. Wer nach einer Mahlzeit sucht, die
    Geschmack und Qualität vereint, wird hier also
    definitiv fündig. Inhaber der Favorites Card genießen zudem
    besondere Vorteile und können Punkte bei jeder
    Bestellung sammeln. Für Weinliebhaber steht eine sorgfältig ausgewählte Weinkarte
    bereit, die den Besuch abrunden.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/umfassende-betrachtung-des-vulkan-vegas-cashback-programms/

  5. Inmitten der Tiroler Berge befindet sich die perfekte Oase für Casinospieler.
    Natürlich haben Österreicher die Möglichkeit, bei zahlreichen weiteren österreichischen Casinos online
    zu zocken. Diesen Trend haben auch die Casinos Austria
    längst erkannt und Sie finden auf win2day das offizielle Internetangebot
    der österreichischen Casinos. Das Glücksspiel im
    Casino online wird im Jahr 2025 immer beliebter.

    Dort werden herkömmliche Preise berechnet, für Hausgäste
    gibt es also keine Ermäßigung. So kann man für 23 Euro
    beispielsweise Jetons im Wert von 25 Euro und für 27
    Euro Jetons um Wert von 30 Euro erhalten. Regelmäßig sind Musiker
    und Kabarettisten zu Gast, wie zum Beispiel Joesi Prokopetz oder Pepi Hopf.

    Es bietet eine breite Palette an Casinospielen,
    Unterhaltungsmöglichkeiten und Turnieren, sodass jeder hier etwas Passendes
    findet – egal ob Anfänger oder erfahrener Spieler.
    Es bietet eine breite Palette an klassischen und modernen Casinospielen, die
    für jeden etwas bieten. Das Casino in der Tiroler Landeshauptstadt bietet neben aufregenden Glücksspielen ein schön eingerichtetes Bistro mit angeschlossener Lounge.
    In vielen österreichischen Spielcasinos gilt ein gepflegter, „smart-casual“ Dresscode.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallhalle.de/alles-uber-24-casino-cashback-ihr-weg-zu-mehr-spielguthaben/

  6. Diese bekommt das Casino jedoch deutlich leichter, weil sie alle B2B
    Lizenzen der gelisteten Softwareanbieter nutzen können, die
    man unter Type 1 sieht. Ja, in Malta lizenzierte Casinos sind für deutsche Benutzer absolut sicher.
    In Malta lizenzierte Online Casinos bieten Benutzern die gleichen Spiele und Boni wie
    andere Glücksspielseiten.
    Sie sollten es vermeiden, in Offshore Casinos ohne klar
    definierte Zahlungsrichtlinien zu spielen, denn sie sind unsicher!
    Enn Sie daran interessiert sind, ein bestimmtes Spiel im Offshore-Glücksspielhaus zu spielen,
    ist es eine gute Entscheidung, zu prüfen, ob
    es tatsächlich verfügbar ist. Es gibt einfach kein größeres Warnsignal als ein Casino,
    das behauptet, von einer bestimmten Aufsichtsbehörde lizenziert zu sein, wenn
    dies nicht der Fall ist, denn worüber sollte das
    Casino sonst gerne lügen? Vielleicht fragen Sie sich, welchen Prozess
    man durchläuft, um festzustellen, ob man in einem Offshore-Glücksspielhaus spielen sollte oder nicht.

    Wenn Sie neugierig sind, wie die maltesische Aufsichtsbehörde entstanden ist und wie sie bei den Spielern von Offshore
    Casinos an Bedeutung gewonnen hat, dann lesen Sie weiter!

    Der Malta Racing Club bietet eine große Auswahl an Wettangeboten, die Ihnen die Möglichkeit geben, Ihr Wettgefühl unter Beweis
    zu stellen. Das Casino ist rund um die Uhr geöffnet und bietet Ihnen über 200 Spielautomaten sowie Live-Tische und ein Glücksrad, an dem Sie Ihr Glück versuchen können. Die Spielhalle, die als nächstes auf unserer Liste steht,
    ist nach der berühmten Sporthalle in San Francisco benannt,
    in der Steph Curry und seine Golden State Warriors ihre Heimspiele in der NBA austragen. Die Eigentümer haben es geschafft, die Atmosphäre der weltbekannten Casinos aus der Wüste
    in Las Vegas nach Malta zu bringen und haben damit bei Casinofreunden aus
    aller Welt ins Schwarze getroffen. Nach einer umfangreichen Renovierung im Jahr
    2016 erstrahlt das Casino heute in frischem Glanz.

    References:
    https://online-spielhallen.de/ihr-ultimativer-leitfaden-zum-buran-casino-promo-code/

  7. Additionally, there are several chances to win prizes thanksto the Rocket casino bonus promos.
    Since its creation in 2020, the website has grown in popularity because toits extensive game selection and easy payment options.

    3,900 games from 46 reliable sources that arewell-known for their excellent quality and solid
    reputation are availableon the website. Game rules, bonus terms, and account management features are clearly presented, reducing confusion and enhancing the overall user experience.
    The platform’s intuitive design minimizes the need for support contact by making information easily accessible.
    The support team is trained to handle a wide range
    of issues, from account verification and payment questions
    to technical troubleshooting and bonus inquiries.
    Online casinos have revolutionised the way Australians enjoy
    gambling, offering a vast array of online casino games and
    real money games right at their fingertips. The platform focuses primarily on casino games,
    so players looking for sports betting may be disappointed.
    Beyond being a fun rocket play online casino experience,
    it shows how DraftKings is using innovation, exclusive content, and player engagement
    to attract and retain casino users. By combining
    smart use of casino rocket bonuses with a clear understanding of banking options, you can focus more on the fun of the rocket launch game and less on logistical
    hassles. If you prefer a more interactive experience, there are
    live dealer games where you can play with real dealers in real-time.
    This casino offers a wide selection of games, exciting bonuses, and easy-to-use features.

    The platform offers multiple support channels, including
    live chat, email, and phone support. RocketPlay
    Casino takes customer support seriously, ensuring players
    have a smooth and enjoyable experience. Casino offers a seamless gaming experience on mobile devices.
    RocketPlay Casino knows how to keep players excited with its generous bonuses and promotions.
    The RocketPlay Casino user interface is designed to be simple
    and intuitive, making it easy for players to find their favorite games and features.
    Everyone may enjoy spinning the reels, playing the tables,
    or playing live dealer games.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/vip-betting-insights/

  8. Welcome to Royal Reels Casino, where new players are guided meticulously
    into a gaming world brimming with breathtaking excitement, lucrative possibilities,
    and premium experiences. Maximize your Royal Reels experience today—discover what makes our casino truly remarkable with
    unmatched bonuses, gamified promotions, and tailored,
    detailed terms and conditions. With a player-first approach, our engaging
    interface, and an unwavering focus on security and support, Royal Reels Casino stands out as a
    premier destination for online gaming enthusiasts. Join Royal Reels for an immersive experience and benefit from our secure platform, comprehensive support, and manifold
    gaming options. Reliable casinos don’t just offer a handful of
    games – they give you access to hundreds of pokies, live tables, and
    more from well-known software developers.
    By combining entertainment with stringent security measures, Royal Reels Casino stands out as a
    trustworthy destination for online gaming enthusiasts. Players
    at Royal Reels Casino can enjoy a seamless gaming experience knowing that their personal and financial information is protected by
    top-notch encryption technology. Players can easily navigate through
    the carefully curated categories present in the FAQ section, such as payment
    methods, bonuses, technical issues, and more.
    Start your frequent check-ins today and embrace the true spirit of Royal Reels Casino—the intense gaming realm awaits each visit and possibility to emerge victorious
    in rich gaming environments. Beyond simple access, taking control
    of your account ensures that you remain in the best position to take advantage of everything Royal Reels offers.

    Your regular log-ins can translate into immediate loyalty rewards and access to
    time-limited promotions. If your login remains problematic, use our live chat feature to gain instant assistance or reset your password using
    the ‘Forgot Password? Logging into Royal Reels Casino marks the beginning of your strategic exploration of the unparalleled gaming
    offerings available on our platform. Get started today and lay the foundation for a delightful,
    potentially rewarding gaming path at Royal Reels Casino.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/goat-spins-casino-in-australia-real-money-casino-wins/

  9. The Legion of Extraordinary Dancers and the YouTube
    Symphony Orchestra selected their membership based on individual
    video performances. Whereas YouTube’s inherent
    ability to allow presidents to directly connect with average citizens was noted, the YouTube
    content creators’ new media savvy was perceived necessary to better cope
    with the website’s distracting content and fickle audience.

    President Obama held a meeting at the White House with leading YouTube content creators not only
    to promote awareness of Obamacare but more generally to develop ways
    for government to better connect with the “YouTube Generation”.
    Senate introduced a resolution condemning Joseph Kony 16 days after the “Kony 2012” video
    was posted to YouTube, with resolution co-sponsor Senator Lindsey Graham remarking that the video
    “will do more to lead to (Kony’s) demise than all other action combined.” YouTube
    has enabled people to more directly engage with government, such as in the CNN/YouTube presidential debates
    (2007) in which ordinary people submitted questions to U.S.
    presidential candidates via YouTube video, with a techPresident co-founder saying that
    Internet video was changing the political landscape.

    This adds another layer because your not just playing against the house, your climbing ranks against other players.
    Theres a whole competitive element with the Intensity
    leaderboard where top players compete for extra prizes. Intensity showing live
    cashouts is a subtle but important trust signal that theyre actually processing withdrawals not just collecting deposits.
    Too many casinos are black boxes where you deposit money and just hope they’ll
    pay out when you win. Intensity online casino offers 5% commission on referrals.

    In 2010, it was reported that nearly a third of the videos with advertisements were uploaded without permission of the copyright holders.
    The majority of YouTube’s advertising revenue goes to the publishers and video producers who hold the rights to their videos; the company retains 45%
    of the ad revenue. In the United States as of November 2020, and
    June 2021 worldwide, YouTube reserves the right to monetize any video on the platform, even if their
    uploader is not a member of the YouTube Partner Program.
    DeFranco argued that not being able to earn advertising revenue on such videos was “censorship by a different name”.
    In September 2016, after introducing an enhanced notification system to inform users of these violations, YouTube’s policies were criticized
    by prominent users, including Philip DeFranco and Vlogbrothers.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/bellagio-resort-overview/

  10. Crown Melbourne is committed to providing a safe, secure, and responsible gaming environment — both onsite and online.
    Use your Crown Rewards card or account across Crown Melbourne and Crown Online Casino to collect points and redeem exclusive offers.
    Whether you’re a tourist or a local, Crown Melbourne is a must-visit
    landmark for gaming and leisure. Visitors also enjoy live performances,
    movie theatres, shopping, and spa services — all under one roof, making Crown Melbourne a complete entertainment resort.
    Crown’s “Play Safe” initiative ensures that gaming remains an enjoyable experience while promoting awareness and
    help-seeking behaviour among guests. Visitors have access to support services,
    including multilingual counselors, time-limit
    tools, and a voluntary self-exclusion program.
    Discover the largest and most prestigious casino in the Southern Hemisphere.
    Situated on Southbank, steps from major attractions, with riverfront views, luxury
    shopping, and easy transport access. Access private gaming salons, luxury transfers, VIP lounges, personal hosts,
    and bespoke packages for elite guests and
    high rollers.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/video-poker-rules-progressive-jackpot/

  11. In addition to the welcome bonus, Skycrown Casino offers various ongoing promotions such as
    weekly bonuses, cashback offers, and exclusive bonuses for VIP players.

    Skycrown Casino offers a wide selection of games, including slots, live
    casino games, table games, and sports betting. The SkyCrown app for iPhone and Android offers games developed by paramount iGaming software providers,
    known for delivering fair and quality products.
    To enjoy the best of two worlds – the brick-and-mortar and online casinos, SkyCrown suggests testing its collection of 70+ live
    dealer games.
    Those who deposit with cryptocurrencies, like Bitcoin or Ethereum,
    enjoy seamless transactions with no withdrawal limits.
    Everything you need to know about playing at SkyCrown Australia.
    Zoome10casino.com – Fast-paced and full of energy. We believe your focus should be on the game, not on banking hassles.

    Responsible gambling means staying in control, keeping play
    fun, and knowing when to stop.

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/craps_strategie/

  12. The ability of AI chatbots to accurately process natural human language and automate personalized service in return creates clear benefits for businesses and
    customers alike. Over time, chatbot algorithms became capable of more complex rules-based programming and even natural language processing, enabling customer queries to
    be expressed in a conversational way. In addition, conversational
    analytics can analyze and extract insights from natural language conversations,
    typically between customers interacting with businesses through chatbots
    and virtual assistants.
    Chatbots can make it easy for users to find information by instantaneously responding to questions and
    requests through text input, audio input, or both, without
    the need for human intervention or manual research.
    True to its promise of not requiring any code, the course teaches
    how to visually create chatbots with Watson Assistant and how to
    deploy them online through a handy WordPress plugin. Learn to create useful chatbots without writing any code in IBM’s
    Building AI Powered Chatbots Without Programming course.
    Looking to leverage the benefits of chatbots in your job?

    References:
    https://blackcoin.co/online-casino-games-overview/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.